We all know Crucial P2. It’s an old player in the field of computer storage. But, Kingston is launching new products regularly and NV1 is its new one that promises a great performance at an affordable price.
I know it’s not easy to choose between these both because the offerings may look similar. Both of them come in the budget NVMe category. Both of them have no DRAM cache and lots of other similarities. But, in my opinion, it is very easy to make a decision between the both.
So, in this article, I am going to cover every important thing which will clear everything and by the end of this article, you will go with a decision in your hand. Now, without any further delays, let’s get started.
1. Theoretical Specifications (Comparison)
Let’s uncover and compare the key offerings specified by the companies for these products.
|Specifications||Crucial P2||Kingston NV1|
|Storage Variants||250GB, 500GB, 1TB, 2TB||500GB, 1TB, 2TB|
|Sequential Read Speed||2400 MB/s (Max.)||2100 MB/s (Max.)|
|Sequential Write Speed||1900 MB/s (Max.)||1700 MB/s (Max.)|
|Random 4K Read Speed||500GB: 170,000 IOPS||Not Specified|
|Random 4K Write Speed||500GB: 215,000 IOPS (500GB)||Not Specified|
|Endurance||2TB Variant: 600 TBW||2TB Variant: 480 TBW|
Crucial P2 is capable of offering a better read/write speed. Also, the warranty period of P2 is two years more than the NV1. Let’s test them in the next section.
2. Benchmark Scores
I have tested these both these SSDs using the CrystalDiskInfo Software on my Intel i5 8th Generation laptop with 8 GB 3000MHz RAM. The results are as follows. These tests were done only on 1TB variants and the SSD storage was 0% filled. The results may vary on your system depending on its specs, total storage filled, and various other factors.
|Results||Crucial P2 (1TB)||Kingston NV1 (1TB)|
|Sequential Read (Average)||2105 MB/s||2036 MB/s|
|Sequential Write (Average)||1504 MB/s||1741 MB/s|
|Random 4K Read Q32T16 (Average)||57 MB/s||52 MB/s|
|Random 4K Write Q32T16 (Average)||149 MB/s||127 MB/s|
It is not easy to detect the better one between the both with these benchmark scores. Both the SSDs are almost equal in all terms. So, let’s compare some other things and reach at a fine decision.
If an SSD has high endurance, it means it is reliable and can last longer. So, let’s compare the total endurance of these both and see which one is more reliable.
|Crucial P2 (2TB)||Kingston NV1 (2TB)|
|600 TBW||480 TBW|
Note: TBW means Terabytes Written. It is the total limit of how much data you can read and write on your SSD. The more the TBW, the longer will be your SSD’s life.
4. NAND, DRAM, and Controller
The Crucial P2 is using 96 Layers of Micron’s TLC/QLC 3D NAND. Whereas the NV1 is equipped with only TLC NAND.
If talk about the DRAM, both of them doesn’t have DRAM Buffer. However, these both makes the best use of HMB (Host Memory Buffer) for cache purposes.
Crucial P2 has a single-core, 4-channels Phison E13T controller.
Kingston NV1 has a dual-core, 4-channels SMI SM2263XT controller.
If we look at the controller, the NV1 has a better offering for you. This might be the reason why NV1 is capable of beating the P2 even after having similar specifications.
5. Price Difference
Price is another one of the main factors which may impact your decision. So, it is worth understanding that whether the higher price of the Crucial P2 really worth it or is it fine to go with the latest NV1.
|Crucial P2 (250GB)||$33.24||–|
|Crucial P2 (500GB)||$59.99||Kingston NV1 (500GB)||$64.93|
|Crucial P2 (1TB)||~$107.33||Kingston NV1 (1TB)||$104.99|
|Crucial P2 (2TB)||$236.99||Kingston NV1 (2TB)||$199.99|
You can clearly see that all variants of Crucial P2 as slightly pricier as compared to the NV1. But, is it really worth this price. Let’s discuss that below.
My Opinion on Crucial P2 vs Kingston NV1
Both of these SSDs are great and somewhat similar if we look at the offerings. However, there are certain differences between the prices and the benchmark scores. But, because NV1 has a better controller and a lesser price, I would suggest you choose this one for sure.
But, the NV1 has a 3-years warranty whereas the P2 has 5-years and this is another thing to consider. So, if the warranty period is much important for you, it is better to go with the P2.
Both the brands have a great reputation in the computer storage market. But, if you ask me to pick one from these, I would go with the NV1.
Thanks for reading.